Baseball has always held a special place in the world of video gaming, dating back to 1961 with the release of BBC Vik: The Baseball Demonstrator. Over the decades, the genre has evolved to offer a wide array of experiences that cater to every type of baseball enthusiast. From hyper-realistic simulations that let you step into the shoes of your favorite players to Fantasy Baseball leagues where you build and lead your own team to victory, the options are boundless.
In this article, we’ll take a look at some of the must-play baseball games that every fan should try.
MVP Baseball 2005
Released in February 2005, MVP Baseball 2005 quickly became a fan favorite and still holds a special place in the hearts of gamers. Developed by EA Vancouver and Electronic Arts, this game was available on PlayStation 2, GameCube, Xbox, and Microsoft Windows. Featuring then-Red Sox star Manny Ramirez on the cover, it offered an immersive experience like no other.
From the absence of Barry Bonds to the myriad of game modes, including Dynasty and Owner Modes, players had endless options to explore. The scenario editor mode allowed fans to recreate historical match-ups or concoct imaginative scenarios, adding another layer of depth.
The game’s pitching and batting mechanics were exceptionally polished, making use of the analog/thumbstick for a more realistic feel while challenging players’ timing and precision.
Even nearly two decades later, MVP Baseball 2005 remains a landmark in sports gaming, showcasing innovative features and gameplay that continue to resonate with baseball enthusiasts.
MLB The Show 21
Released in April 2021, MLB The Show 21 showcased San Diego Studio’s continued prowess in crafting top-tier baseball simulations. Available on PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, and Xbox Series X and Series S, this was the first game in the series to span across multiple platforms, including Xbox. The game featured San Diego Padres shortstop Fernando Tatís Jr. on the cover, highlighting its emphasis on young talent and dynamic gameplay.
What set this installment apart was the refined pitching mechanics, offering players enhanced control and realism. The transition to ninth-generation consoles was marked by impressive visual upgrades, making the virtual ballparks more lifelike than ever.
Despite the anticipation for groundbreaking changes, the developers focused on polishing existing features, delivering the most fine-tuned baseball experience yet. While some may have been looking for new game modes, the refinement and perfect execution of classic elements like Road to The Show and Diamond Dynasty solidified MLB The Show 21 as a must-play for baseball aficionados.
The game stands as a testament to the studio’s confidence and expertise, further elevating the series’ legacy.
Out of the Park Baseball 24
Released in March 2023, Out Of The Park Baseball 24 brings baseball management to new heights with its unparalleled depth and detail. Developed by Out of the Park Developments for Microsoft Windows, Linux, and macOS, it stands as the pinnacle of the long-running OOTP series.
This iteration boasts significant graphical improvements and a more immersive franchise mode, further refining what was already considered one of the best aspects of its predecessor.
Fully licensed by MLB, OOTP 24 provides an exhaustive array of options for management enthusiasts. Players can dive into historical MLB seasons dating back to 1871, scout talent, negotiate contracts, and engage in intricate trade talks. The game also offers an advanced analytics system, allowing for a statistical approach that mirrors real-life baseball management strategies.
The 2023 edition has garnered praise from critics, fans, and even notable MLB figures such as Boston Red Sox owner John W. Henry. Its combination of depth, authenticity, and updated features make OOTP 24 a must-play for anyone serious about baseball management simulations.
MLB The Show 23
Released in March 2023, MLB The Show 23 extends the franchise’s legacy by introducing a captivating, historical story mode. Available on PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X and Series S, Xbox Cloud Gaming, and Nintendo Switch, this installment sees San Diego Studio deliver both innovation and tradition.
One of the marquee features is its focus on the rich history of African American leagues before Jackie Robinson broke the MLB color barrier in 1947. This offers players an educational and engaging journey through an important era in baseball history.
In addition to this compelling narrative, MLB The Show 23 brings new life to fan-favorite modes. Diamond Dynasty receives fresh updates, while the new Captain Cards mode allows for rapid skill enhancement, adding strategic depth.
For Derek Jeter fans, the Captain Edition of the game is a must-have, celebrating the iconic New York Yankees shortstop. While it may not revolutionize the series, MLB The Show 23 stays true to its roots, enhancing what makes it the go-to baseball gaming experience for enthusiasts and newcomers alike.
MLB The Show 17
Released in March 2017, MLB The Show 17 brought a refined and engaging experience exclusive to PlayStation 4, developed by San Diego Studio. This installment featured MLB Hall-of-Famer Ken Griffey Jr. on the cover, setting the tone for a nostalgic yet innovative entry in the series.
A standout component was the new “Pave Your Path” mode, an evolution of the “Road To The Show” story mode. “Pave Your Path” allowed players to make significant, plot-altering decisions, giving a more immersive and dynamic character development experience.
Complementing the enriched story mode, “Diamond Dynasty” received notable enhancements, including new features and the addition of legendary players, providing more depth and entertainment. The game also delivered minor but impactful tweaks across various gameplay mechanics, ensuring a polished experience despite a few minor glitches.
MLB The Show 17 effectively combined nostalgic elements with fresh innovations, solidifying its status as a benchmark for quality in baseball gaming and pointing to a promising future for the franchise.